And some options that only throw errors with the new PM.
Details
Diff Detail
- Repository
- rG LLVM Github Monorepo
Event Timeline
-enable-new-pm is going to be removed from opt? What is that patch doing that?
polly/test/Support/defaultpipelines.ll | ||
---|---|---|
0–6 |
polly/lib/Support/RegisterPasses.cpp | ||
---|---|---|
587 | b) (POSITION_AFTER_LOOPOPT is not supported by the NPM because there is no extension point). Maybe remove it entirely? |
it's explicitly for the legacy PM -> new PM migration, which has basically already happened. on discourse we've talked about how to deal with the option, and we're now trying to remove it
polly/lib/Support/RegisterPasses.cpp | ||
---|---|---|
587 | done. that extension point looks like it was specifically for loop passes, but due to the legacy PM design it's possible to add non-loop passes and have it still run like that. so perhaps not worth porting to the new PM |
Some other Polly options become inaccessible using any pipeline builder: PollyACC (-polly-target), static expansion (-polly-enable-mse), polyhedral info (-polly-enable-polyhedralinfo), and JSON export (-polly-export).
-polly-target, -polly-enable-mse and -polly-enable-polyhedralinfo are experiments that are effectively unmaintained now and I think should also be removed in this patch (that is, the cl::opt options, I can remove the passes separately at some point unless someone jumps in to update them to the NPM)
I will commit a patch that makes -polly-export usable with the NPM.
polly/lib/Support/RegisterPasses.cpp | ||
---|---|---|
587 |
do you mean impossible? I can only add loop passes at that point while Polly uses function passes. That extension point was added to the legacy pass manager by @grosser explicitly to implement -polly-position=after-loopopt. I am not aware of any other use of it. In any case, I never used that position and therefore fine with removing it. |
MaximalStaticExpansion expansion was actually already ported to the NPM in D125870. I made the NPM pass builder use it in rGb150d34c47ef.
That is, only the flags -polly-target and -polly-enable-polyhedralinfo remain to have no function without the legacy pass manager (other than throwing a fatal error) and should be removed with this patch.
b) (POSITION_AFTER_LOOPOPT is not supported by the NPM because there is no extension point). Maybe remove it entirely?