This revision follows up on the conversation titled:
[llvm-dev] Understanding and controlling some of the AVX shuffle emission paths
The revision adds a vblendps-based implementation for transpose8x8 and further distinguishes between and intrinsics and an inline_asm implementation.
This results in roughly 20% fewer cycles as reported by llvm-mca:
After this revision (intrinsic version, resolves to virtually identical assembly as per the llvm-dev discussion, no vblendps instruction is emitted):
Iterations: 100 Instructions: 5900 Total Cycles: 2415 Total uOps: 7300 Dispatch Width: 6 uOps Per Cycle: 3.02 IPC: 2.44 Block RThroughput: 24.0 Cycles with backend pressure increase [ 89.90% ] Throughput Bottlenecks: Resource Pressure [ 89.65% ] - SKXPort1 [ 0.04% ] - SKXPort2 [ 12.42% ] - SKXPort3 [ 12.42% ] - SKXPort5 [ 89.52% ] Data Dependencies: [ 37.06% ] - Register Dependencies [ 37.06% ] - Memory Dependencies [ 0.00% ]
After this revision (inline_asm version, vblendps instructions are indeed emitted):
Iterations: 100 Instructions: 6300 Total Cycles: 2015 Total uOps: 7700 Dispatch Width: 6 uOps Per Cycle: 3.82 IPC: 3.13 Block RThroughput: 20.0 Cycles with backend pressure increase [ 83.47% ] Throughput Bottlenecks: Resource Pressure [ 83.18% ] - SKXPort0 [ 14.49% ] - SKXPort1 [ 14.54% ] - SKXPort2 [ 19.70% ] - SKXPort3 [ 19.70% ] - SKXPort5 [ 83.03% ] - SKXPort6 [ 14.49% ] Data Dependencies: [ 39.75% ] - Register Dependencies [ 39.75% ] - Memory Dependencies [ 0.00% ]
An accessible copy of the conversation is available here.