This is an archive of the discontinued LLVM Phabricator instance.

[SDAG] Introduce a combined set to the DAG combiner which tracks nodes which have successfully round-tripped through the combine phase, and use this to ensure all operands to DAG nodes are visited by the combiner, even if they are only added...
ClosedPublic

Authored by chandlerc on Jul 23 2014, 3:58 AM.

Details

Summary

...during the combine phase.

This is critical to have the combiner reach nodes that are *introduced*
during combining. Previously these would sometimes be visited and
sometimes not be visited based on whether they happened to end up on the
worklist or not. Now we always run them through the combiner.

This fixes quite a few bad codegen test cases lurking in the suite while
also being more principled. Among these, the TLS codegeneration is
particularly exciting for programs that have this in the critical path
like TSan-instrumented binaries (although I think they engineer to use
a different TLS that is faster anyways).

However, there are also a worrying number of cases in x86 where this
causes us to combine things into a DAG that misses the expected patterns
and instruction selects to something pretty terrible. =/ The vector sign
extension patterns in particular seem quite broken by this.

Again, assistance would be appreciated from those familiar with other
targets to evaluate the nature of these changes. I haven't even really
vetted Mips or R600 for correctness. That's the primary reason for
needing pre-commit review here.

If anyone wants to take a look at the x86 regressions around sign
extension and add some patterns or fix the combines to survive this
change that would be amazingly helpful...

Diff Detail

Repository
rL LLVM

Event Timeline

chandlerc updated this revision to Diff 11807.Jul 23 2014, 3:58 AM
chandlerc retitled this revision from to [SDAG] Introduce a combined set to the DAG combiner which tracks nodes which have successfully round-tripped through the combine phase, and use this to ensure all operands to DAG nodes are visited by the combiner, even if they are only added....
chandlerc updated this object.
chandlerc edited the test plan for this revision. (Show Details)
chandlerc added a subscriber: Unknown Object (MLST).

A couple of random other notes about this patch....

  • I did benchmark the compile time impact. For a "worst case" scenario in

my mind of taking a single bitcode for all of clang and running it through
just llc I observed a 3% slowdown of llc with this patch. I expect that to
translate into more like 1% or 2% of slowdown for LTO, and well under that
for normal compiles (which have the frontend in the critical path). So the
runtime cost isn't great, but isn't terribly scary to me.

  • An obvious question is, why still populate the worklist with all the

nodes? The answer is because just starting from the root and letting the
de-dup'ed operand walk handle the rest causes more tests to fail, and I'm
already struggling to drag the test suite kicking and screaming through
these changes. It still might be nice eventually so that we move to a more
principled graph-traversal strategy. It may recover a (very minor) fraction
of the runtime cost, but nothing huge.

  • With this functionality added, I can add legalization support to the last

DAG combine phase and successfully legalize newly created illegal nodes as
we effectively traverse the new nodes. I've successfully implemented the
PSHUFB matching logic on top of this. So this isn't just idle hardening of
the DAG combiner.

echristo accepted this revision.Jul 23 2014, 11:02 AM
echristo edited edge metadata.

I think mips test changes look fine and the patch looks fine as well.

This revision is now accepted and ready to land.Jul 23 2014, 11:02 AM

FYI, discussed this with some folks on IRC too and they seem happy with it.

However, I want to land http://reviews.llvm.org/D4654 (or something similar) first as that will remove the regressions w.r.t. sext from this change.

chandlerc closed this revision.Jul 24 2014, 3:24 PM
chandlerc updated this revision to Diff 11858.

Closed by commit rL213898 (authored by @chandlerc).

llvm/trunk/lib/CodeGen/SelectionDAG/DAGCombiner.cpp